CALLING BRAKE BOFFINS!
CALLING BRAKE BOFFINS!
Okay, so I took my car to MMC on Saturday to get some work done under warranty. Heater and brakes. The brakes were rattling (will be cured with buffers) and my rear caliper was binding.
MMC have just called me. They are replacing the heater and fitted the buffer pads - perfect!
"Now the rear calliper Mr Owen, there seems to be some sort of fluid on the disk and pad. Don't know where it's coming from and I can only suggest that it may of been from a passing Lorry with a oil leak!".
You have got to be joking! A passing lorry!!!
So apart from that, they have no idea where this fluid has come from but want to strip the brake down and clean the disk and pad and charge me...£300!!
So my limited knowledge would tell me that it's probably the piston seal and the fluid is actually brake fluid, therefore a faulty part.
I've contacted the service manager at MMC to look into this as I'm not happy! So, if I do pay for it (which I'm NOT going to do), they will clean it without finding the cause of the fluid leak and I'm back to square one!
Any other suggestions!?
Thanks
Gareth
MMC have just called me. They are replacing the heater and fitted the buffer pads - perfect!
"Now the rear calliper Mr Owen, there seems to be some sort of fluid on the disk and pad. Don't know where it's coming from and I can only suggest that it may of been from a passing Lorry with a oil leak!".
You have got to be joking! A passing lorry!!!
So apart from that, they have no idea where this fluid has come from but want to strip the brake down and clean the disk and pad and charge me...£300!!
So my limited knowledge would tell me that it's probably the piston seal and the fluid is actually brake fluid, therefore a faulty part.
I've contacted the service manager at MMC to look into this as I'm not happy! So, if I do pay for it (which I'm NOT going to do), they will clean it without finding the cause of the fluid leak and I'm back to square one!
Any other suggestions!?
Thanks
Gareth
£300
At £300 for a strip and clean the hourly rate has to be worse than your local Porsche centre (£90/hr) or the mechanic doing the job ain't got a clue what he's doing.
I'm no mechanic but with a little help from a mate we changed front pads and discs, both sides, on my Box(ster) in less than an hour. Then the backs in the same kinda time.
As far as the fluid on the discs, would expect you are right can't really come from anywhere else, not clever to have oily fluids too close to brakes so routing of pipework should all be well away, shocks of course could be the source, but that would be obvious, oh it could be a passing lorry
get real!!!!!
I'm no mechanic but with a little help from a mate we changed front pads and discs, both sides, on my Box(ster) in less than an hour. Then the backs in the same kinda time.
As far as the fluid on the discs, would expect you are right can't really come from anywhere else, not clever to have oily fluids too close to brakes so routing of pipework should all be well away, shocks of course could be the source, but that would be obvious, oh it could be a passing lorry

if evolution don't take care of it, redesign it
Re: CALLING BRAKE BOFFINS!
I'd ask why they didn't stop the lorry driving through the workshop.Gareth wrote: "Now the rear calliper Mr Owen, there seems to be some sort of fluid on the disk and pad. Don't know where it's coming from and I can only suggest that it may of been from a passing Lorry with a oil leak!".

They must be useing expensive wrags to clean the oil off too if it'll cost £300.
mmm.... one can of brakecleaner fluid: £ 3,-
- Lift car
- Take wheel off
- Remove upper bolt of caliper
- Twist caliper back
- Spray fluid on disc and pads
- Clean with cloth
- Spray again
- Clean with cloth
- Put caliper back
- Put bolt back
- Put wheel back
- Lower car
If that's worth £ 150,- I'll consider moving to Scotland in hours from now
- Lift car
- Take wheel off
- Remove upper bolt of caliper
- Twist caliper back
- Spray fluid on disc and pads
- Clean with cloth
- Spray again
- Clean with cloth
- Put caliper back
- Put bolt back
- Put wheel back
- Lower car
If that's worth £ 150,- I'll consider moving to Scotland in hours from now

Yvo, as straight forward as that?YvoTuk wrote:mmm.... one can of brakecleaner fluid: £ 3,-
- Lift car
- Take wheel off
- Remove upper bolt of caliper
- Twist caliper back
- Spray fluid on disc and pads
- Clean with cloth
- Spray again
- Clean with cloth
- Put caliper back
- Put bolt back
- Put wheel back
- Lower car
If that's worth £ 150,- I'll consider moving to Scotland in hours from now
There was a joke a couple of years ago about the 750 machine.
They seemed to go through a phase where every SE owner's car came out with a bill in a multiple of £750, so we guessed that there was only one button on the service dept calculator and they just pressed it a few times if it was a bigger job!
They seemed to go through a phase where every SE owner's car came out with a bill in a multiple of £750, so we guessed that there was only one button on the service dept calculator and they just pressed it a few times if it was a bigger job!

2010 Honda VFR1200F
1990 Honda VFR400 NC30
2000 Honda VTR1000 SP1
2000 Kawasaki ZX-7R
1990 Honda VFR400 NC30
2000 Honda VTR1000 SP1
2000 Kawasaki ZX-7R
Yeah.. if there's grease or oil on the discs/pads, the only thing to do is to clean them with this brakecleaner.Gareth wrote: Yvo, as straight forward as that?
....the guy on the pone must be thinking you're an absolute nutter if he's telling it's from a truck passing by.. How should that have happend? Wheels are clean from the outside I assume?
You might want to ask them to check the CV-Joints/boots etc. If they tear apart (or start to fall apart) A LOT OF GREASE will be released on the complete inside of the wheelarch..
Final outcome is they think it looks like some sort of crude oil picked up on the road.
Front disks have been cleaned up but I'm unsure if I should clean the rear disks and pads or replace them with some of Stu's disks.
After a little scare, Graeme has sorted it that the heater will be getting replaced. Magic as that wasn't going to be cheap to fix!
Front disks have been cleaned up but I'm unsure if I should clean the rear disks and pads or replace them with some of Stu's disks.
After a little scare, Graeme has sorted it that the heater will be getting replaced. Magic as that wasn't going to be cheap to fix!